IELTS Writing 12: Discuss Both Views Essays — Giving Equal Weight

Writing 2-topshiriq: Munozara va yechim insholari (Task 2 — Discussion & Problem-Solution Essays) Lesson 1 of 2
Lessons in this topic · 1/2
  1. IELTS Writing 12: Discuss Both Views Essays — Giving Equal Weight
  2. 2 IELTS Writing 13: Problem-Solution Essays — Cause and Remedy Structure

"Discuss both views and give your own opinion"

Bu savol turida sizga ikkita qarash beriladi va siz ikkovini ham yoritishingiz, hamda o'z fikringizni bildirishingiz kerak. Ikki eng katta xato: (1) faqat bitta qarashni yoritish; (2) o'z fikrini umuman aytmaslik. Ikkovi ham Task Response'ni jiddiy pasaytiradi.

Tuzilma — 4 paragraf

1. Introduction. Savolni paraphrase qiling + "ikki qarashni ko'rib chiqaman" + o'z pozitsiyangiz (tezis). Fikringiz kirishdayoq aniq bo'lsin.

2. Body 1 — birinchi qarash. Uni adolatli tushuntiring: nega ba'zilar shunday deb o'ylaydi? Dalil + misol. Bu qarashga siz qo'shilmasangiz ham, uni kuchli ko'rsating.

3. Body 2 — ikkinchi qarash. Xuddi shunday adolatli va batafsil. Teng vazn bering — bir tomonni ataylab zaif ko'rsatmang (strawman qilmang).

4. Conclusion. Ikki qarashni qisqacha eslatib, o'z fikringizni qayta va aniq ayting: qaysi tomon sizningcha kuchliroq.

⚠️ Diqqat — o'z fikringiz QAYERDA? "Discuss both views and give your own opinion" — bu ikkinchi qism majburiy. Fikringiz kirish (tezis) va xulosada aniq ko'rinishi shart. Faqat ikki tomonni sanab, fikrsiz qolish — eng ko'p yo'qotiladigan ball.

Ikki tomonni ulash tili

Birinchi qarash: On the one hand, ... / Those who support X argue that ... / Supporters of X point out that ...

Ikkinchi qarash: On the other hand, ... / Others contend that ... / However, an opposing view holds that ...

O'z fikringiz: In my view, ... / Personally, I believe ... / While both sides have merit, I am inclined to think ...

Model esse — qism-qism oching

Savol: "Some people believe that a university degree is the best route to a successful career, while others think practical work experience is more valuable. Discuss both views and give your own opinion."

Introduction: "There is an ongoing debate about whether a university degree or hands-on work experience offers the better path to career success. This essay will consider both views before arguing that, although a degree is valuable, practical experience is often more decisive."
Paraphrase + "both views" + aniq tezis (experience often more decisive).

Body 1 (degree view): "On the one hand, supporters of higher education argue that a degree provides deep theoretical knowledge and formal qualifications. Many professions, such as medicine and law, are closed to those without a relevant degree. University also develops critical thinking that employers value."

Body 2 (experience view): "On the other hand, others contend that hands-on experience teaches skills no lecture can. By working from an early age, individuals build professional networks and learn how real workplaces operate. A young entrepreneur, for example, may gain more from running a small business than from years of study."

Conclusion: "In conclusion, while both a degree and work experience have clear merits, I believe the most successful people combine the two, with real-world skills frequently making the greater difference."
Ikki qarash eslatildi + o'z fikri aniq (experience greater difference).

Amaliyot 1. "Discuss both views and give your own opinion" savolida ikki qarashdan tashqari yana nima SHART?

Amaliyot 2. Talaba birinchi qarashni 5 gapda kuchli yoritib, ikkinchisini faqat 1 zaif gapda "ataylab kuchsiz" ko'rsatadi. Muammo nima?

Amaliyot 3. Qaysi ibora ikkinchi qarashni tabiiy boshlaydi?

Kalit iboralar — Discussion phrases

On the one hand, ... On the other hand, ...
Bir tomondan ... Boshqa tomondan ...
Those who support X argue that ...
X tarafdorlari ... deb ta'kidlaydi
Others contend that ...
Boshqalar ... deb hisoblaydi
both views have merit
ikkala qarash ham asosli
I am inclined to think ...
Men ... deb o'ylashga moyilman
decisive
hal qiluvchi
an ongoing debate
davom etayotgan bahs
to build a network
aloqalar tarmog'ini qurmoq

Xulosa

  • "Discuss both views" = ikki qarash + O'Z fikring (ikkinchisi majburiy).
  • Har qarashni adolatli, teng vazn bilan yoriting — strawman qilmang.
  • Ulash tili: On the one hand / On the other hand; supporters argue / others contend.
  • Fikringiz kirish (tezis) va xulosada aniq bo'lsin.
2-topshiriq: Munozara va yechim insholari (Task 2 — Discussion & Problem-Solution Essays)
  1. IELTS Writing 12: Discuss Both Views Essays — Giving Equal Weight
  2. 2 IELTS Writing 13: Problem-Solution Essays — Cause and Remedy Structure