The Fork in the Road
The road forks. One branch leads to the city; the other leads into the desert. Two guards stand at the fork, and they both know exactly which is which.
One of them always tells the truth. The other always lies. They look the same, they sound the same, and you have no way of telling which is which.
One of these two has never told the truth in his life.
The famous question is this. You point at one road and ask a guard: "If I asked the other guard whether this road leads to the city, what would he say?"
He answers "Yes."
Answer to type: which road do you take — the road you pointed at, or the other road?
💡 I want a nudge
Work through both cases: what if you are speaking to the truthful guard, and what if you are speaking to the liar? Notice they give the same answer.
Log in to send an answer
Reading is free for everyone. Sealing an answer, earning points and appearing on the solver wall need an account.
Log in🔓 The solution
Answer: the other road
Suppose the road you pointed at really does lead to the city, and work out what each guard would say.
- You asked the truthful guard. He reports honestly what the liar would say. The liar, asked about the correct road, would answer "No". So the truthful guard says "No".
- You asked the liar. The truthful guard would answer "Yes" — so the liar reports the opposite and says "No".
- Either way the answer is "No". The question passes through exactly one liar no matter whom you ask, so the two cases collapse into one.
- You heard "Yes", which is the opposite. So the road you pointed at does not lead to the city: take the other road.
The trick: you cannot find the liar, and you do not need to. By asking about what the other one would say, you force every answer through exactly one lie — and one lie always flips the truth in the same direction. Then you simply do the opposite of what you are told. Deliberately building a known error into a measurement, so you can subtract it, is a real technique far beyond this puzzle.