SAT R&W 72: Inference vs Outside Knowledge — Staying Inside the 60 Words

O'qish Mantiqiy xulosa (Inferences) 3-dars, jami 5
Shu mavzudagi darslar · 3/5
  1. SAT R&W 70: Inferences — “Which Choice Most Logically Completes the Text?”
  2. SAT R&W 71: The Blank Is Always at the End — Reading Toward It
  3. SAT R&W 72: Inference vs Outside Knowledge — Staying Inside the 60 Words
  4. 4 SAT R&W 73: Hedged Conclusions — may, suggests, is likely to
  5. 5 SAT R&W 74: Inferences — Mixed Practice

Bilimingiz sizga qarshi

4-darsda to'rt tuzoqni sanagandik, va ulardan biri tashqi bilim edi. Inferences turida u boshqa hamma turdagidan ko'ra kuchliroq ishlaydi.

Sabab oddiy: bu turda sizdan xulosa chiqarish so'ralyapti, ya'ni matnda so'zma-so'z yozilmagan narsani aytish. Miya buni «o'ylab top» degan ruxsat deb tushunadi — va o'zi bilgan hamma narsani ishga soladi.

📝 Namuna:

Farq shu:
Xulosa — matndagi faktlardan majburan chiqadigan narsa.
Tashqi bilim — matndagi faktlar bilan mos keladigan, lekin ulardan chiqmaydigan narsa.

Ikkinchisi juda ishonarli tuyuladi, chunki u ko'pincha rost.

⏱ ~70 soniya

Barmoq sinovi

1. Variantni tanlang. Keyin darrov so'rang: «matnning qaysi so'zlari buni majburlaydi?»

2. O'sha so'zlarni ko'rsating. Barmoq bilan, aniq joyga. Ikki-uch so'z bo'lsin.

3. Ko'rsatolmasangiz — javob emas. «Bu shunday bo'lishi kerak-ku» degan tuyg'u isbot emas.

⚠️ Tuzoq: O'zbek o'quvchi uchun eng xavfli mavzular: Orol dengizi, Ipak yo'li, Samarqand va Buxoro, paxta, Al-Xorazmiy, Navoiy, iqlim o'zgarishi. Bu mavzularda siz matndan ko'ra ko'proq bilasiz — va aynan shu sizni yiqitadi. Mavzu tanish bo'lsa, barmoq sinovini ikki marta qiling.

Ishlangan namuna

Between the eighth and the twelfth centuries, paper-making spread westward from Central Asia along the trade roads, reaching Baghdad, then Cairo, then the Iberian peninsula. Each of those cities already had a large body of scribes copying manuscripts on parchment when paper arrived. Records of book prices in each city fall sharply within two generations of paper's arrival and not before. The sequence indicates that

Which choice most logically completes the text?

  1. paper was invented in Central Asia and carried west by merchants.
  2. the fall in book prices in each city followed the arrival of paper rather than preceding it.
  3. parchment was no longer used for books once paper became available.
  4. the scribes in those cities resisted the introduction of paper.
⏱ ~70 soniya

Yechim

Bu matn o'zbek o'quvchi uchun ataylab xavfli: Ipak yo'li, Samarqand qog'ozi, Bag'dod — hammasi tanish. Shuning uchun barmoq sinovini qat'iy qo'llaymiz.

Matn nimani aytadi? Faqat uch narsani: (1) qog'oz g'arbga tarqaldi; (2) har shaharda oldindan kotiblar bor edi; (3) kitob narxi qog'oz kelganidan keyin ikki avlod ichida tushdi — oldin emas.

Uchinchi faktdagi and not before — butun savolning kaliti. Muallif uni ataylab qo'shgan.

TO‘G‘RIthe fall in book prices in each city followed the arrival of paper rather than preceding it — aynan within two generations of paper's arrival and not before ning qayta ifodasi. Barmoq shu yerga qo'yiladi.
TUZOQpaper was invented in Central Asia and carried west by merchantstashqi bilim. Matn qog'oz tarqalganini aytadi, ixtiro qilinganini emas — va savdogarlarni umuman eslatmaydi. Bu dunyoda rost bo'lishi mumkin, lekin matnda yo'q.
TUZOQparchment was no longer used for books once paper became availablematndan kuchliroq. Matn pergamentning to'xtaganini aytmaydi — u faqat qog'oz kelganini aytadi. «Yangi narsa keldi» ≠ «eskisi yo'qoldi».
TUZOQthe scribes in those cities resisted the introduction of paperyangi ma'lumot. Kotiblar eslatilgan, lekin faqat bor edi deb. Ularning munosabati haqida bir og'iz ham yo'q — qarshilik hikoyasini o'quvchi o'zi qo'shadi.
📌 Eslatma: Diqqat qiling: to'g'ri javob eng kamtarin variant edi. U shunchaki matndagi vaqt tartibini qaytardi. Qolgan uchtasi qiziqarliroq hikoya aytardi — va aynan shuning uchun noto'g'ri.

The rivers feeding a large inland sea were diverted for irrigation, and the sea shrank over the following decades. A dam later separated its northern basin from its southern one. The northern basin, no longer draining southward, began to refill, and fish returned to it within a few years; the southern basin continued to dry. Since neither basin received more river water than before, the northern recovery indicates that

Which choice most logically completes the text?

A ninth-century scholar's treatise on calculation describes a system of ten symbols, including one for nothing, and explains how any quantity may be written with them. The treatise survives only in Latin translations made three centuries later. Those translations disagree with one another about several passages, and in each case where they disagree, at least one of them uses a term that had no equivalent in the language of the original. This pattern suggests that the disagreements

Which choice most logically completes the text?

A caravanserai excavated on a trade route contains stabling for about forty animals and sleeping space for roughly the same number of people. Its storerooms, however, could hold several times the goods that forty animals could carry in one journey. The building stands a day's travel from the next such site in either direction. The layout suggests that the caravanserai

Which choice most logically completes the text?

Honeybee colonies across a region declined sharply over five years. Beekeepers reported the same rate of loss whether their hives stood beside orchards, beside grain fields, or in woodland with no farming within several kilometres. Within each of those settings some apiaries lost most of their colonies while others lost almost none, and the difference followed which beekeeper managed them rather than where the hives stood. The pattern suggests that the main cause of the losses

Which choice most logically completes the text?

Kalit so'zlar — Key vocabulary

to precede
oldin kelmoq
to retain water
suvni ushlab qolmoq
to reverse a decline
pasayishni orqaga qaytarmoq
a basin
havza
to arise in the process of ~
~ jarayonida paydo bo'lmoq
stabling
otxona, hayvonlar uchun joy
lodging
tunash joyi
internally inconsistent
o'z ichida ziddiyatli

Xulosa

  • Xulosa matndan majburan chiqadi; tashqi bilim unga shunchaki mos keladi.
  • Barmoq sinovi: matnning qaysi so'zlari buni majburlaydi? Ko'rsatolmasangiz — javob emas.
  • Tanish mavzuda (Orol, Ipak yo'li, Al-Xorazmiy) sinovni ikki marta qiling.
  • To'g'ri javob odatda eng kamtarin variant bo'ladi; qiziqarli hikoya aytgani — tuzoq.
  • Matndagi eng g'alati tafsilot javobning kalitidir.